I generally won't give cash to homeless people on the street when they ask for it. I suspect that there are times when the money is truly needed and will be well-spent, but I also suspect that most times giving them cash is just enabling them to pursue things that aren't healthy. I have no way of distinguishing which of those scenarios applies, so I prefer to help the homeless in other ways. I have two responses when asked for cash:
- If I'm in a hurry, or broke, I say: "No, sorry".
- If I have time and money, I say: "Sorry, can't give you any cash, but can I buy you something to eat?".
Here are three anecdotes from my experiences using these two comments:
1) As I was walking to a lunch meeting with some colleagues, I was telling them about Socks and Gloves. A homeless man approached us and asked for cash, and I replied "no, sorry". He responded by yelling "No time for the homeless, huh? You hate homeless people, don't you? Nice suit, but no cash to help somebody?" and on and on as we walked away. My colleagues thought this was kind of funny, but it just made me feel sad for the guy.
2) As I'm walking into Safeway, a guy asks me for cash, and I tell him that I don't have cash, but I'd be happy to buy him something to eat, and ask him what he wants. I suggested a deli sandwich, and he replied: "That's all I've had to eat for a week, and I'm honestly kind of sick of them." Then, he kind of hemmed and hawed a bit, and asked: "Would it be too much to ask for some bread and brie cheese, and water?" Then he immediately backed off from that - I distinctly remember him saying something like "sorry, sorry, that's probably not appropriate for me". I assured him that I had no problem with brie and bread. I asked him to come in with me, but he pointed out that Safeway will hassle him if he comes into the store and walks around with me. So, I went in, bought my stuff, and got him some brie, bread, and bottled water. He couldn't believe it when I came out - he was really pleased to have something good to eat other than the deli sandwiches. It was cool - we talked for a few minutes, and just connected as people.
3) Several years ago I would to a particular Starbucks three or four times a week at around 8:00 AM. There was a guy who waited outside this 'bucks every morning, asking everyone for cash. I would always offer to buy him breakfast, and he would always respond, very politely, "No thank you, my belly's full." There came a point where, due to business travel, I hadn't been there in a couple of months. My first time back, before he even asked for change, I said "Hi" to him, and he replied "No thank you, my belly's full". Then he looked surprised, and we both laughed, and ended up chatting for a few minutes.
Just handing over some cash seems like a bad idea for both sides: it encourages the hander to feel like they've done their part (even though they probably haven't really helped, and may have made things worse); and it encourages the handee to think of them as an ATM machine. It means that neither side of the transaction is really thinking about the other one as a person.
If you can give time or money, but not both, I will always encourage you to give time. You can volunteer with us (see
this page for more info), or check out some of the groups listed under the "Local Resources" heading on this page. If you want to give money, well, you could help us out (see
this page for more info), or again give it to one of those "Local Resources". In other words, when someone asks you for money on the street, you can either say "yes" or "no", but those aren't your only choices for helping the homeless.
I'm curious - how do you respond when asked for cash?